Welcome to Mike's Mr. Pizza
Located in Milton, WI, Mike's Mr. Pizza has carved a niche as a beloved carry-out and delivery spot. Renowned for its diverse pizza offerings, including BBQ Chicken and Mediterranean Chicken, the restaurant also boasts fantastic burgers and a variety of sandwiches. Customers rave about the friendly service and the welcoming atmosphere curated by Mike himself, who embodies a genuine passion for food and community. With vegetarian options available and impressive quality across the menu, Mike's Mr. Pizza stands out as more than just a pizzeria; it’s a hidden gem that truly values customer satisfaction and delicious cuisine.
-
16 Front St, Milton, WI 53563, United States16 Front St, Milton, WI 53563, United States Hotline: +1 608-868-4800
Welcome to Mike's Mr. Pizza, a delightful eatery nestled in the heart of Milton, Wisconsin. Located at 16 Front St, this hidden gem serves not only exquisite pizzas but also an array of delectable dishes that make it a must-visit destination for food lovers.
At Mike's, the menu shines with variety. While pizzas steal the spotlight, the offerings extend far beyond to include fantastic burgers, mouth-watering gyros, and flavorful sandwiches. For those seeking a fulfilling meal, the Seasoned Chicken Buff Chix Sandwich stands out, featuring a perfectly cooked chicken breast topped with melted American cheese and zingy hot sauce, all for just $7.99. If burgers are your thing, then the 1/3 lb Hamburger served on a toasted bun at $6.49 will surely satisfy your cravings. And let’s not forget the classic Gyro, with juicy meat tucked in warm pita, complemented perfectly by a cucumber sauce, fresh tomato, and onion – all for $7.49.
But it’s not just the main courses that impress. Diners rave about the side sauces, which include marinara, garlic butter, and ranch, each priced at just $1.25. These small add-ons elevate your meal, making every bite a delight. You can wash it all down with refreshing beverages, including a 2 Liter Soda for $4.00.
What truly sets Mike's Mr. Pizza apart is the warmth of its service. Customers frequently highlight the friendly ambiance fostered by the owner, Mike, who has been a cherished member of the Milton community since 2013. His dedication shines through in both the food and the welcoming atmosphere. As one satisfied customer, Joshua, puts it, "Mike is one of Milton's nicest humans," and it’s easy to see why visitors keep returning to this beloved establishment.
Mike's Mr. Pizza has truly carved out a spot as a local favorite, with glowing reviews that emphasize its bubbling energy and outstanding food quality. Whether you're in for a quick carry-out or a delivery to your doorstep, you'll find that the delicious dishes and attentive service make each visit a memorable experience. Don't just take my word for it – indulge in the culinary treasures of Mike's Mr. Pizza. You won’t be disappointed!
This spot (carry out or delivery only) is a secret gem. Tons of great pizza’s like the name says, sure, but the rest of their menu is what’s notable. Fantastic burgers for one, the other sandwiches, sides, apps also great. Should not be a hidden gem but a well known one!
This is my 1st time ordering and it is AWESOME! I got half Cheeseburger and half Philly. So good I will definitely be ordering more. Also thank you for being open on Easter.
Amazing pizza! My son loves the gyro pizza and has a few other favorites. He has a few of the sandwiches on his list to try too (is still working through the menu to pick his top favorites). I love the vegetarian options! We've always had great service as well.
I’ve been going to Mikes Mr Pizza since 2013. Mike is one of Milton’s nicest humans. He’s always positive and friendly. Serves up great tasting food and is great at giving students their first job opportunities. You can tell he truly has a passion for pizza, good food and making people happy. If you haven’t been here (which would be hard to believe) then you need to stop in to the see pizza king. You won’t be disappointed.
The food here is great! The employees are always friendly and courteous from the order takers to the delivery drivers. Orders always arrive quickly and accurately. Highly recommend if you enjoy eating delicious food!
I can’t speak to the atmosphere of the restaurant since I had delivery. We love the gyros, but this time we ordered the fish dinners, very impressed with how delicious the fish was. Will definitely order it again.
Stopped in about an hour to close (i know. I felt bad) for a couple burgers while we did laundry. Younge man working the counter was very nice and even brought over our food when it was done. Only gripe is the lack of napkins in the bag but overall food was so good. loved the smash burger.
This is a bake and take place. We get the frozen pizza's and bake them at home. We're an hour and a half away, so we bought 8 pizzas. They are so good. Well be back again Mike, but next time we won't forget to call ahead.